For years, students and staff at
Corona del Sol High School have
complained about a musty odor and
headaches, presumably a result of
foul air circulated by the school’s
deteriorating heating and air
conditioning plant.
More than seven years ago, district
officials determined that the system
needed to be replaced and sought
funding from the state’s School
Facilities Board, which turned them
down.
Since then — and particularly during
the last two years — complaints
about polluted air and inadequately
cooled classrooms in the late summer
months have increased significantly,
according to Tempe Union
Superintendent Steve Adolph.
Testing was performed again last
fall, once again identifying the
30-year-old system as the origin of
elevated mold and carbon dioxide
levels in the air, and recommending
replacement.
Once again, the Facilities Board
rejected the district’s request to
replace an HVAC system that at least
twice has been called too old and
too small to produce clean air for
the now more than 2,700 students
attending CdS.
Tempe Union has appealed that
decision and is awaiting a ruling by
Administrative Law Judge Lewis Kowal
in the next two weeks.
Should Kowal reject the appeal,
Adolph has said that the district is
considering joining a suit filed
against the state by the non-profit
Center for Law in the Public
Interest to secure the necessary
funds.
Meanwhile, the district is
proceeding with replacement of a
portion of the AC system with funds
that originally were earmarked for
maintenance repairs at other schools
in the district, which now must put
their needs on hold.
The Tempe City Council and the Tempe
Union High School District, along
with many school staff, students at
Corona and their parents, have said
they fully expect the judge to
render the only acceptable decision
regarding the right to breathe clean
air in a public building.
We indeed hope that their optimism
is justified.
However, should the judge rule
otherwise, a major public initiative
needs to be launched to help our
state leaders understand, and
respond to, this community’s
non-negotiable demand for a safe and
healthy environment in our schools.
An editorial appearing elsewhere has
suggested that the Tempe district
should somehow find a way to pay the
required costs or close off part of
the campus. We disagree. The
estimated $17 million cost to make
the necessary repairs is beyond any
local school district’s capacity to
absorb, particularly in what now has
become an emergency situation.
This is where state support not only
makes sense but is the only logical
solution.
Simply stated, students should not
have to swelter in classrooms and
inhale foul, potentially dangerous
air because the state doesn’t deem
such conditions an emergency.
The current deplorable conditions at
Corona are the result of the state
placing building and maintenance
funds for schools at the mercy of
annual bond-override requests and
deferring necessary maintenance at
schools, setting them aside until
the need reaches crisis proportions.
Every homeowner knows from
experience that it costs more in the
long run when maintenance is
deferred rather than undertaken
within a logical, reasonable
timeframe.
It’s time for the state to confront
a real and immediate threat, and to
honor its mandate to guarantee the
health and safety of children in our
public schools.